The Decemberists | As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again Review

by Tom Faddis

The Decemberists, known for their narrative-driven lyrics and eclectic musical style, released their latest album, As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again, on June 14, 2024. This album marks another chapter in the band’s storied career, blending folk-rock with indie influences to create a rich, melodic, and fetching sound.

As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again is a journey through time and emotion, capturing the essence of The Decemberists’ signature style. The album opens with “Burial Ground,” a track that sets the tone with its catchy folk melody and introspective lyrics. From there, the listener is taken on a sonic adventure through songs exploring themes of love, loss, and resilience.

“Oh No!” showcases the band’s ability to blend historical rhythmic structure with modern sensibilities. The six-eighth groove pulls from folk structures. The lyrics paint a vivid picture, and the instrumentation incorporates rich horn elements and contemporary indie rock backing vocals and guitars.

“Long White Veil,” a medium-tempo, more reflective song, delves into themes of memory and nostalgia. The melancholic melody is complemented by Colin Meloy’s evocative vocals, making it a highlight of the album. The folk and Americana mix of sounds adds to the song’s appeal.

“Don’t Go to the Woods” has an interesting arpeggiated guitar part and catchy chorus, providing a contrast to the other tracks on the album. The lyrics explore the idea of looking forward while honoring the past, a recurring theme throughout the album. The folk influence is strong in the instrumentation, and the vocal harmonies are beautiful.

“All I Want Is You” is a classic The Decemberists song, blending rich storytelling with intricate musical parts and robust vocals. The song’s layered instrumentation and dynamic vocal structure make it a fitting centerpiece for the album.

The Decemberists are known for their literary approach to songwriting, and As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again is no exception. The lyrics explore various themes, from personal introspection to historical narratives. The recurring motifs of time and memory tie the album together, creating a cohesive listening experience. The production on this album is top-notch, with each track meticulously crafted to highlight the band’s strengths. The lush vocals and diverse instrumentation create a rich sonic landscape, while the mixing ensures that every element is balanced and clear. The album was produced by longtime collaborator Tucker Martine, whose expertise is evident in the final product.

As It Ever Was, So It Will Be Again shows The Decemberists’ enduring ability to create music that is deeply personal and universally resonant. The album’s blend of storytelling, introspective lyrics, and diverse instrumentation makes it a standout addition to the band’s discography. Whether you’re a longtime fan or a new listener, this album will surely captivate and inspire.